Sunday, April 29, 2012

This week too soon for Detroit Tigers, baseball to allow Delmon Young to play

While Tigers outfielder Delmon Young has the right to due process, both through baseball's system and the legal system, the Tigers also have the right to not play him.
And in the aftermath of Young's reported drunken, anti-Semitic outburst in New York early Friday morning, Young should not play for the Tigers until the situation sorts itself out. It clearly has not on a number of different levels.
What Young is accused of is beyond disrepectul to a large segement of Southeastern Michigan's population. It should not be as simple as, "if he is cleared to play he will play," as Tigers general manager Dave Dombrowski stated over the weekend.
Why play him? So the Tigers can insult a significant portion of their fan base? Do the Tigers need a lesson in the Holocost in order to understand playing Young as soon as this week would be beyond  insenstive?
I would hope not.
Look, I can't stand political correctness run amuck, but that isn't the case here. An incident like this doesn't blow over in just a few days. Nor should it.
Part of this is baseball's responsibility. Young should not be cleared to play anytime soon by the commissioner's office. Part of this is the Players Association's responsibility.Their stance should be getting Young help before he comes back, if it is deemed necessary. Or clearing his name before he comes back, if he is being unfairly accused. It should not be simply just getting Young back on the field as soon as poosible.
It'd be different if Young's pay was suspended during this process, but it isn't.

1 Comments:

Anonymous woody said...

How would this scenario be managed outside of baseball? The employee would be placed on administrative leave. The business would then eventually decide whether to fire the person over the incident or allow a conditional return to work.

It seems like the "restricted list" is MLB's version of administrative leave. I don't see that Tigers or MLB have reacted in an inappropriate way since the incident. Unofficial reports say that he will be suspended by MLB.

Unlikely that the Tigers would have grounds to cut Delmon without owing him rest of this year's salary...unless he fails to fulfill the conditional terms of return.

5:34 PM 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home